PUBL0260 - Blog

Political Islam and the Future of NATO

Political Islam has failed to replace the former Soviet Union as the unifying force for NATO countries. The Alliance will probably never be the same as it was.

The collapse of the former USSR in 1991 was as surprising as it was a game changer in international life. The common enemy of the West since the WWII was dissolved into fifteen independent states and the East-West Cold War that had characterized world politics for decades dissipated into oblivion. In the absence of the inimical Communist foe how could the Western political and military unity be preserved? What was to be the new raison d’etre for the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, NATO?

A decade before the collapse of the Soviet Union an Islamic Revolution in Iran had set off an anti-Western movement amongst Muslims. The hostage-taking of the US diplomats in Tehran in 1979 for 444 days and the killing of the US and French Marines in Lebanon in 1983, orchestrated by radical Muslims in Tehran, were clear sings that anti-Westernism was no longer a monopoly of Communism. There was now an established non-Communist but anti-Western ideology in the international arena that could qualify as a common enemy to further reinforce the cultural identity and the political and military unity in the West.

The clash of civilizations theory by Huntington in 1990s that pitted the West against the rest already focused the minds of Western policymakers on possible new formations in international relations. Their concern was exacerbated by the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, in the US, and the subsequent suicide bombings in Spain and the UK. They proved beyond any shadow of a doubt the anti-Western trait of political Islam. NATO, after all, had found a new enemy to be focused on.

The triumph of President Trump in two elections in 2016 and 2024, however, upended that outlook. In particular, the US National Security Strategy Document released last December did not name political Islam as the main enemy of the US or the West. In fact, it openly cast aside the ‘permanent alliance of the US and Europe’ citing a decline in the continent.

“Should present trends continue, the continent will be unrecognizable in 20 years or less. As such, it is far from obvious whether certain European countries will have economies and militaries strong enough to remain reliable allies. Many of these nations are currently doubling down on their present path.”

This clearly demonstrates an unprecedented divide in approach and assessment in global politics between the two sides of the Atlantic.

The rift was further echoed in a recent statement by President Trump showing his disappointment with NATO allies in refusing to assist the US to open the Straits of Hormoz.

“He went on to describe the alliance as “a paper tiger [without the US],” that Russian President Vladimir “Putin’s not afraid of.””

The breadth and the depth of differences between Washington and her military allies render any immediate or mid-term trans-Atlantic rapprochement rather unlikely. Even a softer approach by future presidents will not be able to readily bring back the old security framework that inevitably bound the US and European states in the same fashion.

Radical Islam has failed to play the same uniting role in the West as the former Soviet Union did for forty-five years. It lacks the coherence, structure and the discipline that the USSR displayed. Reportedly the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence issued a secret report stating that over 140 domestic gangs were ruling the country. At times they appear like groups of bandits competing with one another for supremacy in radicalism and advantages for plundering national resources.

Should the Islamic Republic expectedly fall in Iran political Islam will have lost its main state-patron and thus will be further relegated in the list of common enemies of the West. Though politics is full of surprises, it would be difficult to imagine a future for NATO that would resemble its past.

Author

DISCLOSURE

All written content of this article on this site is the exclusive copyright and property of Strategy International (SI) Ltd and the author who has written to It.

To note, the opinions stated do not necessarily reflect the official policies of Strategy International.

No prior use in part or in its complete form, written, words, maps, charts or statistical, numerical information can be made, unless there is a written prior request and consent by the author and Strategy International and its legal representative.

All requests should be directed at info@strategyinternational.org

error: Content is protected !