Q & A US Elections
Francis Schortgen
Will Donald Trump be more successful in passing his own vision of the world to US foreign policy mandates during his second term?
Compared to his first administration, when a range of experienced advisors (“adults in the room”) worked hard to temper his worst impulses, Trump will likely surround himself with loyalists in a second term, potentially making it easier to implement certain aspects of his vision. Meanwhile, Trump’s highly transactional approach to foreign policy––lacking a clear and coherent grand strategy on critical issues, notably dealing how to deal with a revanchist Russia under Putin or an assertive China under Xi Jinping––and his mercurial tendencies may yet result in heightened geopolitical turbulence, uncertainty, and risk, undermining his own vision. Given that the U.S. does not have the luxury or capability to deal unilaterally with many pressing geopolitical challenges, his vision may increasingly clash with the need for cooperation, coordination and compromise. Reassuring U.S. allies around the world that an “America First” approach does not equate to an “America Alone” posture would be critical in navigating these choppy waters. He may well have earned some successes with this approach in his first term, but past success is no guarantee of future performance.
Will the polarised political exchanges within the US dealing with agendas that have widespread societal impact, both in the US and around the world, continue?
The extensive and entrenched political polarization in the U.S. has become the new normal. Should the House race (currently too close to call) result in a divided Congress, it will likely reinforce the perception of the U.S. as a dysfunctional democracy. Conversely, if Trump should benefit from a Republican-controlled Congress, polarization within the American electorate is unlikely to subside; in fact, it may intensify, driven by divisive issues like abortion rights. In this hyper-partisan climate, U.S. foreign policy toward China has been a rare exception, and likely will remain so for the foreseeable future. However, on critical global issues such as climate change, persistent American polarization is likely to exacerbate international frustration at a time when coordinated action is urgently needed. Against this backdrop, enduring U.S. political divisions could drive consequential geopolitical realignments, diminishing American credibility, legitimacy, and soft power on the world stage.
Michael Grossman
Q1 Will Donald Trump be more successful in passing his own vision of the world to US foreign policy mandates during his second term?
The U.S. president is embedded in a vast bureaucracy, much of which lies beyond their direct control. This system often operates in ways that can limit a president’s ability to implement policies effectively. In some cases, it can even undermine their agenda. So, the question becomes: how well can Trump bring this bureaucracy under his control? I suspect he won’t be very successful. We saw with Trump that he isn’t particularly interested in the intricacies of governance; he prefers big, showy gestures where he can make bold statements and attract attention. This approach is more about showmanship than governance.
However, a president can shape global expectations through the bully pulpit—what they say matters, and Trump likes to make attention-grabbing statements. His criticism of NATO, for example, had an impact, even if the policy didn’t fully align with his rhetoric. During his first term, he made controversial statements, but the actual policies were less radical than many expected. Ultimately, he followed a fairly traditional nationalist approach to foreign policy.
In the end, Trump’s approach to both foreign and domestic issues is highly transactional, which seems to reflect the preferences of many Americans. If he accomplishes anything significant in U.S. foreign policy, it may be this shift toward an even more transactional outlook. While the U.S. has always had some degree of pragmatism in its foreign policy, Trump’s stance on NATO highlighted this. He was criticized for demanding that NATO members contribute more, but this has been an ongoing issue; Trump was simply more blunt, saying openly what past administrations had often kept private.
Q2 Will the polarised political exchanges within the US dealing with agendas that have widespread societal impact, both in the US and around the world, continue?
There is no question that the polarization in the US will continue and it will impact foreign affairs. We are already seeing the narrative of Russian/Irainian/Chinese/etc. election interference in the media. There will be a lot of folks, who are now outside of government, who will try to label his foreign policy as catering to despots (or whatever term they choose) and Trump will naturally push back because he will not want to tarnish his electoral victory.
Prof. Dr. Francis Schortgen
Commentary: Short Q&A by Prof. Dr. Francis Schortgen and Prof. Michael Grossman
Q & A US Elections
Francis Schortgen
Will Donald Trump be more successful in passing his own vision of the world to US foreign policy mandates during his second term?
Compared to his first administration, when a range of experienced advisors (“adults in the room”) worked hard to temper his worst impulses, Trump will likely surround himself with loyalists in a second term, potentially making it easier to implement certain aspects of his vision. Meanwhile, Trump’s highly transactional approach to foreign policy––lacking a clear and coherent grand strategy on critical issues, notably dealing how to deal with a revanchist Russia under Putin or an assertive China under Xi Jinping––and his mercurial tendencies may yet result in heightened geopolitical turbulence, uncertainty, and risk, undermining his own vision. Given that the U.S. does not have the luxury or capability to deal unilaterally with many pressing geopolitical challenges, his vision may increasingly clash with the need for cooperation, coordination and compromise. Reassuring U.S. allies around the world that an “America First” approach does not equate to an “America Alone” posture would be critical in navigating these choppy waters. He may well have earned some successes with this approach in his first term, but past success is no guarantee of future performance.
Will the polarised political exchanges within the US dealing with agendas that have widespread societal impact, both in the US and around the world, continue?
The extensive and entrenched political polarization in the U.S. has become the new normal. Should the House race (currently too close to call) result in a divided Congress, it will likely reinforce the perception of the U.S. as a dysfunctional democracy. Conversely, if Trump should benefit from a Republican-controlled Congress, polarization within the American electorate is unlikely to subside; in fact, it may intensify, driven by divisive issues like abortion rights. In this hyper-partisan climate, U.S. foreign policy toward China has been a rare exception, and likely will remain so for the foreseeable future. However, on critical global issues such as climate change, persistent American polarization is likely to exacerbate international frustration at a time when coordinated action is urgently needed. Against this backdrop, enduring U.S. political divisions could drive consequential geopolitical realignments, diminishing American credibility, legitimacy, and soft power on the world stage.
Michael Grossman
Q1 Will Donald Trump be more successful in passing his own vision of the world to US foreign policy mandates during his second term?
The U.S. president is embedded in a vast bureaucracy, much of which lies beyond their direct control. This system often operates in ways that can limit a president’s ability to implement policies effectively. In some cases, it can even undermine their agenda. So, the question becomes: how well can Trump bring this bureaucracy under his control? I suspect he won’t be very successful. We saw with Trump that he isn’t particularly interested in the intricacies of governance; he prefers big, showy gestures where he can make bold statements and attract attention. This approach is more about showmanship than governance.
However, a president can shape global expectations through the bully pulpit—what they say matters, and Trump likes to make attention-grabbing statements. His criticism of NATO, for example, had an impact, even if the policy didn’t fully align with his rhetoric. During his first term, he made controversial statements, but the actual policies were less radical than many expected. Ultimately, he followed a fairly traditional nationalist approach to foreign policy.
In the end, Trump’s approach to both foreign and domestic issues is highly transactional, which seems to reflect the preferences of many Americans. If he accomplishes anything significant in U.S. foreign policy, it may be this shift toward an even more transactional outlook. While the U.S. has always had some degree of pragmatism in its foreign policy, Trump’s stance on NATO highlighted this. He was criticized for demanding that NATO members contribute more, but this has been an ongoing issue; Trump was simply more blunt, saying openly what past administrations had often kept private.
Q2 Will the polarised political exchanges within the US dealing with agendas that have widespread societal impact, both in the US and around the world, continue?
There is no question that the polarization in the US will continue and it will impact foreign affairs. We are already seeing the narrative of Russian/Irainian/Chinese/etc. election interference in the media. There will be a lot of folks, who are now outside of government, who will try to label his foreign policy as catering to despots (or whatever term they choose) and Trump will naturally push back because he will not want to tarnish his electoral victory.
Authors
DISCLOSURE
All written content of this article on this site is the exclusive copyright and property of Strategy International (SI) Ltd and the author who has written to It.
To note, the opinions stated do not necessarily reflect the official policies of Strategy International.
No prior use in part or in its complete form, written, words, maps, charts or statistical, numerical information can be made, unless there is a written prior request and consent by the author and Strategy International and its legal representative.
All requests should be directed at info@strategyinternational.org
Search
Recent Articles
Topics
Categories