An article by Jerome Vitenberg
During autumn 2024, as polls indicated the potential return of Republican nominee Trump to the White House, the world of international affairs literally froze in anticipation of him taking the reins of global affairs[1]. Even before his inauguration in January 2025, those who believed that the US was no longer a global leader received a harsh awakening[2].
President Trump’s return is set to reshape global power dynamics through three key mechanisms: the indirect influence of domestic policies abroad, the active promotion of core Western values on the world stage, and direct interventions in international conflicts that break with outdated paradigms.
Trump’s domestic policies have already begun to impact the world. Initiatives led by figures such as Elon Musk – focusing on government efficiency and improved public funds management – have earned praise from foreign politicians and are viewed by citizens abroad as models[3]. It is likely that the so-called DOGE effect will ripple across continents, influencing elections wherever significant segments of the population are dissatisfied with government spending.
Similarly, the administration’s tough stance on illegal immigration, and its efforts to combat fraud, crime, and drug trafficking, resonate with societies that have long struggled with these issues[4].
Building on these domestic influences, the administration is also actively promoting core Western values worldwide. A prime example is Vice President Vance’s commanding speech at the February 2024 Munich Security Conference[5]. Rather than focusing solely on external threats, Vance addressed internal challenges by emphasizing the fundamental rights – free elections, free speech, and overall freedom – that governments, particularly in Europe, must guarantee to their citizens.
After years of American policy in retreat on the global stage, the new administration now wields not only a sheriff’s badge but also a guiding compass, symbolizing a return to American exceptionalism. Far from the isolationism once predicted, the US now seeks peace and prosperity in a stable, democratic world. This renewed domestic confidence naturally translates into a more assertive international posture.
Regarding foreign intervention, the current US administration is addressing major global issues beyond trade and tariffs. Topics such as the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, the challenge posed by China in the Indo-Pacific, and initiatives in denuclearization and de-weaponization are being closely monitored and will shape future policy decisions. Undeniably, Trump’s methodology in tackling these issues is marked by his unique capacity to break existing paradigms.
The most glaring example of Trump’s atypical approach in international relations can be seen in his plan to solve the Gaza crisis. His recent proposal to transform the Gaza Strip into a “beautiful place” reminiscent of a world-class riviera – by relocating its current residents – made headlines[6]. He explained that the relocation is necessary to provide Gazans with a decent, safe life away from sites of destruction, rubble, and unexploded ordnance.
For decades, proposals involving the transfer of populations – whether through the mass relocations orchestrated by the British during the partition of India and Pakistan or the modern notion of a “voluntary transfer” – have been condemned. By breaking this taboo, Trump shifted the moral responsibility for caring for the Gazan population from Israel to its closest geographical and historical neighbors – Jordan and Egypt – and subsequently to the entire region and beyond.
Due to their unique historical ties and complex relationships with the Muslim Brotherhood – from which Hamas derives – both General Sissi and the Hashemite Dynasty immediately opposed relocating Gazans into their countries[7]. They view the relocation of the Gazan population as a threat to their regimes, preferring instead to let tensions simmer in their own regions against Israel. Historically, they opposed Israel on nationalistic and religious grounds and played central roles in the Arab–Israeli wars. Later, as Israel grew stronger and peace agreements were brokered, Amman and Cairo evaded their responsibilities toward their Arab brethren in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza, thereby gaining leverage to press Israel for territorial and other concessions. In parallel, as non-democratic regimes with significant internal discontent, maintaining Israel as the Jewish and Western adversary in the Middle East enabled them to rally their youth, religious leaders, trade syndicates, and military forces against Israel – thereby deflecting criticism of their own internal failings.
In recent months, many have questioned the purpose of these peace treaties. It has long been a mantra among Israeli political and military experts that a cold peace is far preferable to losing soldiers at the border. Nonetheless, tough questions remain regarding the behavior of these peace partners. For instance, how has Egypt either allowed or ignored the construction of tunnels from the Sinai to Israel? Such actions have enabled Hamas to generate wealth and extort the population in Gaza while bolstering its capacity to threaten Israel. More importantly, the recent militarization of Sinai under Egyptian control – the buildup of personnel [8]and equipment in both its army and navy – has alarmed Israel, particularly since these moves violate the peace treaty clauses[9].
More broadly, even forty years after signing its peace treaty with Israel, Egypt has done little to curb the anti-Israeli, antisemitic rhetoric pervasive in its educational system, media, trade syndicates, and political circles[10]. While some speak of a “cold peace,” the reality increasingly resembles a cold war. Meanwhile, Jordan has been vociferous in condemning Israel during the Gaza conflict, and more generally in the last years in disseminating anti-Israeli propaganda through international institutions and the media[11].
This situation, however, is hardly conducive to regional peace, as maintaining Hamas’s control over Gaza is far riskier in the long term for Egypt and Jordan than temporarily accepting the relocation of those at risk. Hamas is a terrorist organization – a highly centralized, totalitarian regime reminiscent of North Korea – and the only way to eradicate its influence is to sever the connection between the group and the Arab population it indoctrinates and exploits.
After several years free from Hamas’s grip – allowing sufficient time to rehabilitate the Strip and dismantle its propaganda, educational programs, and mafia-like threats – Hamas’s toxic ideology will have no host in which to take root.
The threat posed by Hamas to Israel, as well as to Jordan, Egypt, and the West, would then be eliminated. Therefore, Trump’s plan presents a prime opportunity for Egypt and Jordan to extricate a grave threat from the region.
It may be that the benefits Israel will receive from Trump’s plan deter Jordan and Egypt from adopting it. Indeed, due to its strategic location and deep roots in the Arab-Palestinian narrative, Gaza has long posed a significant security threat to Israel. With two million residents effectively imprisoned under a totalitarian regime that employs force and propaganda to justify its bloody agenda, the Strip has become a nest of hate – a pressure cooker against Israel. Until October 7, 2023, Israel believed it could coexist with this regime. That era is over. Following a barbaric massacre, Prime Minister Netanyahu made his position clear: no more Hamas, and no more threats from Gaza.
To persuade King Abdullah and General Sissi of the humanitarian rationale and political logic behind President Trump’s vision, they must first understand that their anti-Israeli obsession is driving them toward the collapse of their peace treaties with Israel – whether by crossing the red line on agreed clauses or by provoking domestic backlash as their people grow weary of the hatred directed against Zionism.
Egypt and Jordan have the potential to transform the prevailing anti-Israeli mantra and foster peaceful, genuine relations with Israel. An alternative plan proposed by an Arab initiative might have merit – or it might not. However, neither Israel in the post–October 7 era nor the US under President Trump will endorse any plan that fails to eliminate Hamas and neutralize the threats from Gaza against Israel.
Egypt, Jordan, and other regional players should quickly realize that Israel will not be destroyed by war or by false promises of peace. There is no time for more “land for peace” or multi-state solutions – whether two, three, or four states. True and lasting peace is in the best interest of the Arab states as much as it is for Israel.
The longer autocratic governments delay educating their people about peace, prosperity, and democracy, the more they will amplify a poison that will eventually undermine their regimes – sooner or later, and if later, even more acutely for future generations.
It is time to initiate a genuine peace. There’s a new sheriff in town – armed with both a badge and a compass – and a bold vision for the Middle East.
REFERENCES
-
Robert C. O’Brien, “The Return of Peace Through Strength: Making the Case for Trump’s Foreign Policy,” Foreign Affairs, July/August 2024, published June 18, 2024. ↑
-
Timothy Garton Ash, Ivan Krastev, and Mark Leonard, Alone in a Trumpian World: The EU and Global Public Opinion After the US Elections, Policy Brief, European Council on Foreign Relations, January 15, 2025, https://ecfr.eu/. ↑
-
Martin Coulter, “EU Lawmakers Split on DOGE for Europe: ‘We Need Something Like This,’” Politico, January 22, 2025. ↑
-
Max Griera, “Looking at Trump, Europe’s Far Right Vows to ‘Reconquer’ the Continent,” Politico, February 8, 2025. ↑
-
Christina Lu, “The Speech That Stunned Europe,” Foreign Policy, February 18, 2025, transcript, https://www.youtube.com/live/pCOsgfINdKg?si=cl6qNX9ajEbaHYh2. ↑
-
“Donald Trump, Benjamin Netanyahu Full Joint Press Conference,” The White House, Washington, February 4, 2025, https://youtu.be/0D4M585EF08?si=_EZvpTV2VCwdhf_7. ↑
-
Dan Dyker and Yoni Ben Menahem, America’s Middle East Upheaval: Assessing Egypt and Jordan’s Opposition to Trump’s Gaza Refugee Plan, Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, February 4, 2025. ↑
-
“Egypt Has Great Interest in Preserving Hamas Capabilities, Warns Israeli Intelligence Officer,” Middle East Monitor, February 4, 2025, https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20250204-egypt-has-great-interest-in-preserving-hamas-capabilities-warns-israeli-intelligence-officer/. ↑
-
Herb Keinon, “Is Egypt Violating the Camp David Accords? Israel Raises Concerns – Analysis,” Jerusalem Post, February 19, 2025. ↑
-
MEMRI, “Egyptian-American Political Analyst Magdi Khalil: Egypt Has Never Fully Embraced Peace With Israel, Consistently Violates the Camp David Accords By Treating Israel Like an Enemy, Cooperating With Hamas, Allowing Widespread Antisemitic Discourse,” MEMRI TV, May 22, 2024, https://www.memri.org/tv/egyptian-american-analyst-magdi-khalil-egypt-violates-peace-agreement-with-israel. ↑
-
Jacob Magid, “Jordan’s Abdullah Tells UN That Scale of Israel’s Assault on Gaza Is ‘Beyond Any Justification,’” The Times of Israel, September 24, 2024. ↑